Bringing or Defending a Small IP Claim in Leeds

Author Rich Tea Licence CC  BY-SA 2.0 DEED  Source Wikimedia Commons

 

Jane Lambert

Nearly 10 years ago I wrote How to Bring or Defend a Small Intellectual Property Claim in the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court in NIPC London. I wrote it with litigants in person in mind though I thought it would also be useful to lawyers who do not specialize in intellectual property and patent and trade mark attorneys who do not litigate regularly in the civil courts. It was intended to supplement A Guide to Bringing and Defending a Small Claim by the Civil Justice Council and A Guide to the Patents County Court Small Claims Track which has been replaced by the Guide to the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court Small Claims Track ("the Guide").

Much of that article remains true though there have been a number of developments since then.  The UK has left the European Union which means that IPEC is no longer a Community designs or EU trade mark court. Disputes over unregistered Community designs or EU trade marks that have arisen since 31 Dec 2020 are no longer within the IPEC Small Claims Track's jurisdiction.  The Leeds District Registry and the District Registries of several other major cities have been integrated with the courts in the Rolls Building in London to establish the Business and Property Courts (see my article Launch of a Judicial Super Highway? 12 July 2017 IP Northwest).  As a consequence of that integration it has been possible to bring certain types of small intellectual property claims in Leeds for most of the last 5 years (see Jane Lambert Small Claims Track IP Litigation in Leeds 10 July 2019).  According to Annex A of the Guide small IP claims in Leeds come before District Judge Prest KC.  Since 3 July 2023 most small IP claims litigation has been conducted in the North because Manchester Civil Justice Centre is now the new home of the IPEC Small Claims Track (see Jane Lambert IPEC Small Claims to be managed in Manchester 9 June 2023 IP Northwest).

The sections of How to Bring or Defend a Small Intellectual Property Claim in the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court that continue to apply are those headed "Do you need a Lawyer?" and "Have you got a Case?"  In addition to the pro bono services listed in section 6 of the Guide, I would add IP Pro Bono which is now part of Lawworks, Advocate which was formerly known as "Bar Pro Bono" and my own "Initial Advice and Signposting" clinic which I run in conjunction with Barnsley Business Village.  

It is still necessary for claimants to write a "letter before claim" unless there are very good reasons not to do so but the practice direction referred to in the section headed "Pre-Action Correspondence" has been revoked and replaced with the Practice Direction - Pre-Action Conduct and Protocols (see my article What to do about the new Practice Direction - Pre-Action Conduct 6 May 2015 NIPC Law).  Guidance on the steps to be taken by parties to intellectual property disputes is no to be found in para 6 of the Practice Direction.

The first paragraph of the section headed "Starting the Claim" has to be modified since the Manchester Civil Justice Centre and not the Rolls Building is now the home of the IPEC Small Claims Track and a small IP claim can now be issued out of the Business and Property Courts in Birmingham, Bristol, Cardiff, Liverpool, Manchester and Newcastle as well as Leeds.   If you want a case study of an IP case in one of those other cities, see Small Claims Track IP Litigation in Bristol 24 Feb 2022 NIPC Severn-Hafren.

I would repeat everything else I said in my previous article.  Anyone who wishes to discuss this topic should call me during normal business hours on 020 7404 5252 or send me a message through my contact form.

Small Claims Track IP Litigation in Leeds

Leeds Law Courts
© 2003 Jane Lambert: all rights reserved

Jane Lambert

One of the most interesting announcements of the new Intellectual Property Enterprise Court Guide is the decision to appoint from October 2019 district judges to hear small intellectual property claims in Leeds (see The New IPEC Guide 4 July 2019 NIPC News).

The cases that those district judges will be entitled to hear pursuant to CPR 63.27 will be claims for £10,000 or less for the infringement of intellectual property rights other than patents, registered and registered Community designs, semiconductor topographies and plant varieties. In Small IP Claims, I gave examples of cases that might be suitable for the small claims track and of others that would not.  The claimant must ask for the claim to be allocated to the small claims track in its particulars of claim and no objection should be raised by the defendant.   However, even if a case falls within the jurisdiction of the small claims track and the parties want it to stay there, the court may transfer it to the multitrack if it is likely to take more than a day to try or there is a difficult point of law or factual issue to decide.

Proceedings in the small claims track are governed by CPR Part 27 and the Part 27 Practice Direction as modified by CPR 63.27 and CPR 63.28 and paragraph 63.32 of the Part 63 Practice Direction.  Though successful claimants can obtain final injunctions and orders for delivery up of infringing materials as well as damages or accountable profits they cannot claim interim injunctions.  Liability and the amount of any damages or other pecuniary relief to be awarded are decided at the same time.  Directions are given automatically in accordance with Appendix B or C of the Part 27 Practice Direction after statements of case are exchanged and although the court has power under CPR 27.6 to hold preliminary hearings these are the exception rather than the rule. There is no provision for disclosure and the costs that may be recovered from an unsuccessful party are limited to court fees, £260 if an injunction is sought and a lawyer has been instructed, travelling expenses and loss of earnings up to £95 per witness and up to £750 in experts' fees.

The new IPEC guide indicates that those wishing to bring an IP case in the small claims track in Leeds should use the electronic filing system.

Anyone wishing to discuss this article or small claims track IP litigation generally should call me on 020 7404 5252 or send me a message through my contact page.

The Leeds Business and Property Courts

Leeds Courthouse

© 2005 Jane Lambert: all rights reserved

Jane Lambert

On Monday 10 July 2017, the Leeds Law Society held a reception at BPP Law School to launch the Business and Property Courts in Leeds (see Leeds Law Society Business & Property Court Launch Event).  The Business and Property Courts is an amalgam of the chancery and commercial courts sitting in Leeds and the idea is to integrate those courts with others sitting in London. I mentioned this initiative and discussed its potential significance to the economy of the North in Launch of a Judicial Superhighway?  12 June 2017 IP North West).

As I said in that article, litigators and advocates will have to get used to listing cases in one of 11 specialist lists one of which will be "Intellectual Property" regardless of the nature of the IP right and the court in which the action will proceed.  Having chosen a list the claimant's legal representative will have to choose a court centre where the claim will be issued and where it is to proceed. Advocates will have to get used to settling statements of case in the "Business and Property Courts in Leeds" rather than the name of the Division and the District Registry,

The reason why I say this development affects more than just lawyers is that it should allow any case to be heard in Leeds no matter how big and regardless of the subject matter.  If any kind of work can be done in Leeds there will be less incentive for bright young men and women to leave the city to practise in London. Such lawyers should be able to service entrepreneurs and other creative people which may be far more significant for economic regeneration than the millions to be spent on infrastructure projects for the North.

Should you want to discuss this post or dispute litigation in Leeds generally, call me on 020 7404 5252 or send me a message through my contact form.